Robo-Advisor or ETF: How Do They Compare?

Part of taking control of your finances and planning for the future includes understanding the investment landscape and the options available. When I started learning more about low cost index investing, I had a hard …

Robo Advisor or ETF Header Image of plants on piles of coins

Part of taking control of your finances and planning for the future includes understanding the investment landscape and the options available. When I started learning more about low cost index investing, I had a hard time telling what the difference was between using a Robo-Advisor and investing in Exchange-Traded Funds (ETFs). They both seem to be a broad investment approach that provides portfolio diversity at a low cost, but after trying out both options, I found that each has its unique set of advantages and potential drawbacks, depending on what you’re looking for in an investment strategy. Here’s a breakdown of my findings, which might help you decide which route is best for your financial goals.

Robo-Advisors: The Hands-Off Approach

A robo-advisor (such as WealthSimple) is an online platform that provides automated, algorithm-driven financial planning services with minimal human intervention. Wealthsimple constructs a diversified portfolio using a mix of low-cost ETFs that include stocks, bonds, and Real Estate Investment Trusts (REITS).

Why I Like Them:

  1. Ease of Use:
    • Automation: Robo-advisors take the guesswork out of investing. They automate the entire process, which means I don’t need to be an expert to get started.
    • Rebalancing: These platforms automatically rebalance my portfolio to ensure it stays aligned with my risk tolerance and investment goals.
    • Goal-Based Investing: Most robo-advisors start by asking about my financial goals, risk tolerance, and time horizon. This helps create a tailored investment strategy without any hassle.
  2. Lower Costs:
    • Management Fees: The fees are generally lower than those charged by traditional financial advisors, usually ranging from 0.25% to 0.75% of assets under management (AUM).
    • No or Low Minimums: Many robo-advisors have low or no minimum investment requirements, making them accessible even if I’m just starting out with a modest amount of money.
  3. Diversification:
    • Pre-Built Portfolios: Robo-advisors typically offer diversified portfolios that include a mix of asset classes such as equities, bonds, and sometimes alternative investments.

What Gives Me Pause:

  1. Limited Personalization:
    • Generic Portfolios: While the portfolios are tailored to my risk profile, the level of customization isn’t as in-depth as what I might get from a human advisor or by picking my own stocks or ETFs.
  2. Dependence on Algorithms:
    • Rigid Algorithms: The investment decisions are based on algorithms, which might not adapt well to unexpected market conditions or my unique personal situation.

Exchange-Traded Funds (ETFs): The DIY Path

Exchange-Traded Funds (ETFs) are investment funds that trade on stock exchanges, similar to individual stocks. ETFs hold a collection of assets, such as stocks, bonds, commodities, or a combination of these, and they offer investors a way to buy a broad portfolio of assets in a single transaction. They provide a low cost index investment option (and by passive investing that aims to replicate the performance of a specific market).

Why I Like Them:

  1. Cost Efficiency:
    • Low Expense Ratios: ETFs usually have lower expense ratios compared to mutual funds, which means more of my money stays invested.
    • No Management Fees: Unlike robo-advisors, there are no management fees for holding ETFs, only the brokerage fees when buying or selling them.
  2. Flexibility:
    • Trade Like Stocks: ETFs can be bought and sold during market hours, giving me more control over my trading decisions.
    • Wide Variety: There’s a vast range of ETFs to choose from, covering different sectors, geographies, and asset classes.
  3. Transparency:
    • Holdings Disclosure: ETFs disclose their holdings daily, so I always know exactly what I’m investing in.

What Gives Me Pause:

  1. Self-Management Required:
    • Knowledge and Time: Investing in ETFs requires a good understanding of the market and a time commitment to research and manage my investments.
    • No Automatic Rebalancing: I need to manually rebalance my portfolio to maintain my desired asset allocation, which can be time-consuming.
  2. Trading Costs:
    • Brokerage Fees: Although ETFs are cost-effective, frequent trading can incur brokerage fees, which might reduce my overall returns.
    • Bid-Ask Spread: The difference between the buying and selling price can add to the cost, especially for less liquid ETFs.

My Investment Strategy

In conclusion, choosing between robo-advisors and ETFs in Canada comes down to what you’re comfortable with and what aligns best with your investment goals. Robo-advisors offer a hassle-free, automated approach that’s perfect for those who prefer a hands-off investment strategy. On the other hand, ETFs provide more flexibility and control, ideal for those willing to actively manage their portfolios.

Personally, I like learning about what I’m invested in and taking more control over my investments. I’ve been invested in both robo-advisor funds with Wealthsimple and ETF index funds with Questrade – and I prefer the ETF model. It’s slightly cheaper than having a robo-advisor manage your funds, and gives me better control over my investments.

Whichever path you choose, it’s essential to stay informed and consider your financial goals, risk tolerance, and how much time you’re willing to dedicate to managing your investments. Happy investing!

Leave a Comment